Skip to main content

Is it Columbus Day or Indigenous Peoples’ Day?

 The first recorded celebration of Columbus Day occurred in 1792, when the New York City political organization Tammany Hall commemorated the 300th anniversary of Columbus’ landing on a Caribbean island. Celebrating this “discovery of America” gained popularity throughout the 1800s, particularly among Italian-Americans who, facing the violently anti-Italian xenophobia of the day, were eager to make a positive connection to U.S. history. In 1891, after 11 Italian-Americans were horrifically murdered by a lynch mob in New Orleans, President Benjamin Harrison designated October 21, 1892 a “general holiday” in celebration of the 400th anniversary of Columbus’ landing in an attempt to assuage the angered Italian government.

In 1937, in response to intense lobbying from the Catholic fraternal service order Knights of Columbus, President Franklin D. Roosevelt proclaimed Columbus Day a national holiday. The U.S. Congress added Columbus Day as an official federal holiday in 1968, noting that it was already an established holiday in 45 states.

By designating it a national celebration, Congress had hoped that “the nation would be honoring the courage and determination which enabled generations of immigrants from many nations to find freedom and opportunity in America.” In more recent years, however, the celebration of Columbus Day has fallen under scrutiny for failing to recognize the violence and suffering inflicted on Native peoples by Columbus and other Europeans during American settler colonialism.

Says Megan Hill, Program Director of the Harvard Project on American Indian Economic Development and citizen of the Oneida Nation of Wisconsin:

For Native people in the U.S., Columbus Day represents a celebration of genocide and dispossession. The irony is that Columbus didn’t discover anything. Not only was he lost, thinking he had landed in India, but there is significant evidence of trans-oceanic contact prior to 1492. The day celebrates a fictionalized and sanitized version of colonialism, whitewashing generations of brutality that many Europeans brought to these shores.

Earlier this year, protests for justice in the murder of George Floyd and the Black Lives Matter movement also shifted focus toward the acknowledgment and removal of symbols and tributes to historical oppression. Confederate monuments and symbols of Christopher Columbus became clear targets. Since June, at least 33 statues of Christopher Columbus have been removed throughout the country, including the one in  Wilmington, Delaware. This count includes a number of statues that were vandalized, toppled, and even beheaded by protestors in cities including Baltimore, Maryland; Boston, Massachusetts; St. Paul, Minnesota; and Richmond, Virginia.

South Dakota was the first state to officially un-recognize Columbus Day, changing it to Native American Heritage Day in 1990. Today, 14 U.S. states and more than 130 cities have re-dedicated the day to a celebration of Native American history and heritage. While Delaware does not officially recognize today as an Indigenous Peoples’ Day, it does not designate Columbus Day as an official state holiday, either.

Want to help celebrate Indigenous Peoples’ Day? Here are some recommendations inspired by the Smithsonian National Museum of the American Indian:

Labels

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Left, Right and Center: What is the Political Ideological Spectrum?

You have probably heard a number of terms having to do with the political spectrum. From political quizzes charting your ideology, to debates in Congress, to news featuring Antifa, there seems to be a need for a handy heuristic to solve the problems of partisan politics. Enter the Left-Right political spectrum. But before we dive into the subject a warning: it is important to remember that human beings are complicated and contradictory animals that cannot be mapped on anything as simple as a political spectrum , let alone one with a single axis. Furthermore, there are plenty of voices that would argue that it is an outdated or overly simplistic idea.   Nevertheless, we will take a look at the Left-Right Spectrum, its history, its uses, and its complications in order to make more sense of this political moment and the partisan groups that inhabit it.   Why Right and Left?  The use of the terms left and right date back to the French Revolution. In 1789, the National A...
Post a Comment
Read more

Is there more to life than XX and XY? Getting past the sexual binary

Transgender, nonbinary, intersex, and other queer individuals have more visibility today than ever. While many people have learned a lot about these communities and have accepted their identities, many people remain confused, or are hostile toward the idea of a person feeling that they were assigned the wrong sex at birth, or feeling they don’t belong to either sex. How can a person be assigned the wrong sex? How can there be anything other than male and female sexes? Most of us learned in school that there are two biological sexes, and they are controlled by two chromosomes X and Y. If a person has XX they will be female, and XY will be male. You may have even learned that it is the presence of the Y chromosome that makes someone male, so someone with an extra sex chromosome XXY would still be male. Unfortunately, like so many other things you learned in school, it turns out that your teachers did not tell you the whole story. Biological sex is actually a really complex subject, there...
Post a Comment
Read more

How are sex and gender different? (And why gender reveal parties are problematic)

  **This is a topic that is challenging to write about because the language surrounding it is evolving so quickly. This is just a very broad overview, and it is possible this information may be dated by the time you are reading it. In recent years there has been a distinct uptick in the popularity of gender reveal parties. At these parties expectant parents, family members, and friends find out the “gender” of the baby that is on the way. If you haven’t been invited to one yourself, you have probably seen some of the news stories of gender reveal parties gone wrong , most famously the party that led to the Sawmill Fire in Arizona in 2017. Aside from the potential dangers of using explosives at a family gathering, gender reveal parties have prompted discussion because a baby’s gender can’t be revealed before it’s born, and even its sex is not necessarily wholly represented in an ultrasound image.  In our day-to-day lives people often use the terms sex and gender interchangeab...
Post a Comment
Read more